Close
Your baby is fussy at the breast, feeding every hour, and won’t settle no matter what you try. Somewhere between exhaustion and 3am panic-googling, a diagnosis starts to form in your head: not enough milk. Or maybe it’s tongue-tie. Or maybe you already gave one bottle of formula last week and now you’re convinced you’ve ruined everything.
Here’s the thing worth knowing before any of those conclusions harden into fact: breastfeeding is genuinely surrounded by more myths than almost any other part of new motherhood, and a lot of the panic mothers feel is based on misunderstanding normal newborn behaviour rather than an actual problem. Let’s go through the big ones properly.
This is, by a wide margin, the most common and most damaging breastfeeding myth out there, and it’s worth understanding exactly why it’s misleading. Frequent feeding and fussiness at the breast are normal newborn behaviors, not reliable signs of low supply. Newborn stomachs are tiny, breast milk digests quickly, and cluster feeding bunching feeds close together, often in the evening is a completely typical pattern, not a sign something’s wrong.
In fact, research suggests this exact misunderstanding is one of the leading reasons breastfed babies get unnecessarily weaned onto formula: a mother interprets normal fussiness as hunger caused by insufficient milk, introduces formula to “fix” it, and because the fussiness was never actually about supply in the first place, it often continues regardless, reinforcing the false belief that her milk “wasn’t enough.”
What actually indicates supply, reliably: output, not behaviour. By day five, a well-fed baby should have around 6 to 8 wet diapers and 3 to 4 dirty diapers in 24 hours, with pale, not concentrated, urine. Weight is the other genuine marker, some weight loss in the first few days (up to 7-10% of birth weight) is normal, but your baby should be back to birth weight by 10 to 14 days. If those two things are on track, fussiness alone is not a red flag, however exhausting it feels in the moment.
This is a myth that’s shifted meaningfully in the last couple of years, and it’s worth knowing the current picture, because a lot of circulating advice hasn’t caught up.
A study published in late 2025, following nearly 500 mother-infant pairs from birth through six months, found that infants with untreated tongue-tie had no significant difference in exclusive breastfeeding rates or weight gain at six months compared to infants without it. What did predict lower breastfeeding continuation was something else entirely: maternal concern about milk supply, regardless of whether a tongue-tie was present.
This tracks with a broader shift in the clinical evidence. A 2025 double-blind randomized controlled trial the strongest possible type of study design, where neither parents nor assessors knew which babies received the real procedure versus a sham one, found that frenotomy (the surgical release procedure) did not produce measurable improvements in breastfeeding outcomes in the newborn period. Major paediatric bodies have also cautioned specifically against performing frenotomy pre-emptively for hypothetical future speech or dental concerns, noting the evidence doesn’t support that reasoning either.
None of this means tongue-tie is never relevant, a 2025-2026 audit at one specialist breastfeeding clinic found the majority of infants assessed for tongue-tie, around 63%, were successfully managed through positioning and feeding support alone, without surgery, while the remaining infants did go on to have the procedure after other options were explored first. That’s the current best-practice sequence: skilled, hands-on lactation support first, with surgery considered only if real functional feeding problems persist despite it, not surgery as a first response to a visual assessment alone.
The takeaway: if a diagnosis of tongue-tie is on the table, ask what’s actually been tried in terms of positioning and latch support before committing to a procedure, and know that “gaining weight” doesn’t automatically rule tongue-tie in or out either way some babies compensate and gain weight while still working much harder than they should be to feed.
This is a genuinely common fear, and it’s more nuanced than a flat yes or no. Milk supply works on a basic principle of supply and demand, the more consistently milk is removed, the more your body is signalled to produce. So it’s true that regularly replacing breastfeeds with formula, without expressing in their place, can reduce supply over time if it becomes a frequent pattern.
But an occasional top-up, particularly one recommended for a genuine medical reason like slow weight gain or significant jaundice, is not the supply-destroying event many mothers fear it is. What matters far more than a single bottle is the overall pattern, if you’re breastfeeding or expressing regularly and consistently, supply typically remains resilient to the occasional supplement. The anxiety itself, ironically, can affect supply more than the formula does chronic stress can genuinely interfere with the let-down reflex via the effect of adrenaline on oxytocin release.
If a top-up is medically needed: ask about also expressing at that feed to keep your body’s supply signal intact, rather than simply skipping the breast entirely for that feed.
This one deserves nuance in the other direction. Mild tenderness or sensitivity in the very first week, as your nipples adjust to a completely new sensation, is common and expected. What’s not normal, and shouldn’t be quietly tolerated, is pain that’s sharp, persistent, or gets worse rather than better that’s a signal of an underlying, fixable issue, most commonly a shallow latch, poor positioning, or occasionally tongue-tie, not something to simply endure as “part of breastfeeding.”
The distinction matters because too many mothers fall into one of two unhelpful extremes: assuming all pain is normal and pushing through unnecessary damage, or assuming any pain at all means something is seriously wrong and giving up prematurely. The honest middle ground: some initial tenderness, yes; ongoing sharp pain, no, and if you’re not sure which one you’re experiencing, that’s exactly the kind of thing worth a proper hands-on assessment rather than guessing.
“You need to eat dairy to make milk.” Not true. You need adequate calcium and fluids generally, but there’s no requirement to consume dairy specifically to produce human milk.
“If your baby is gaining weight, nothing else could be wrong.” Not necessarily. Weight gain is one piece of the picture, but a baby can gain weight while still working unusually hard to feed, or while a mother experiences significant pain or difficulty that deserves its own attention regardless of the number on the scale.
“You need to feed on a strict schedule for your body to know when to produce milk.” The opposite is often closer to true rigid, clock-based feeding schedules, particularly in the early weeks, are a well-recognized contributor to reduced milk supply. Feeding driven by your baby’s cues, not the clock, tends to establish supply more reliably.
“Stress dries up your milk supply.” Short-term stress is more likely to affect your let-down (the release of milk) than your actual production, which is exactly why milk sometimes feels like it’s “not coming” during a stressful moment, even though supply itself hasn’t dropped. Deep breaths, a warm compress, or simply a moment of calm can often help the let-down resume.
None of this is meant to dismiss real concerns, some are worth taking seriously, including:
The difference between a genuine problem and normal newborn behaviour usually isn’t obvious from the outside, which is exactly why a proper, hands-on assessment matters more than trying to self-diagnose from a symptom list at 3am.
This is the real value of experienced, hands-on support: someone who can actually watch a feed, check output and weight trends properly, and tell you honestly whether what you’re experiencing is a normal, exhausting-but-fine part of early breastfeeding, or something that genuinely needs addressing. That clarity alone, even without any “fix” needed is often what stops mothers from giving up on something that was actually going fine.
If you’re in Abu Dhabi and want a real answer rather than another Google search at midnight, our breastfeeding support is built around exactly this: a hands-on assessment, honest answers, and a plan based on what’s actually happening, not on myths.
Does a fussy or constantly feeding baby mean I don’t have enough milk?
Not necessarily. Frequent feeding and fussiness are normal newborn behaviours. Reliable signs of adequate supply are wet and dirty diaper counts and steady weight gain, not how often or how fussily your baby feeds.
Does tongue-tie always require surgery to fix breastfeeding problems?
No. Recent research, including a 2025 randomised controlled trial, found frenotomy surgery did not produce measurable breastfeeding improvements in the newborn period, and current best practice recommends trying skilled positioning and latch support first, with surgery considered only if genuine functional problems persist.
Will giving my baby one bottle of formula ruin my milk supply?
An occasional top-up, especially for a genuine medical reason, is unlikely to significantly affect supply. It’s a consistent pattern of replacing breastfeeds with formula, without also expressing, that’s more likely to reduce supply over time.
Is it normal for breastfeeding to hurt?
Mild tenderness in the first week is common and usually improves. Sharp, persistent, or worsening pain is not normal and usually points to a fixable issue like latch or positioning, worth assessing rather than pushing through.
How can I tell if my baby is actually getting enough milk?
Track wet and dirty diapers (aiming for 6-8 wet and 3-4 dirty by day five) and weight, your baby should return to birth weight by 10-14 days. These are more reliable indicators than fussiness or how often your baby wants to feed.
If you’re caught between conflicting advice and just want a clear, honest answer, our midwife services in Abu Dhabi are here to separate what’s actually a problem from what’s simply a normal, hard part of early breastfeeding.
Want a real assessment instead of another myth to worry about? Book a consultation and let’s get you clarity.
Nativacare is your trusted support system led by experienced community midwives for your extraordinary motherhood journey. We at NativaCare believe that the positive motherhood outcome is not a probability but a possibility. Unlock your potential and change your attitude to change your altitude.
YES YOU CAN DO IT.
C2 Bateen tower, 6, Al Hirdiyah Street, 10th Floor, Abu Dhabi
This will close in 0 seconds
This will close in 20 seconds
